Here is my $.02 as I went through this several years ago when I got into the little raft game. I've spent time in both
Flycraft
Things I liked
- it had a frame providing more comfort on long floats
- small enough to throw in a pickup as suggested
- I liked the rack on the stern for carrying gear
Things I didn't like
- the boat was narrow and felt super tippy...almost like a canoe. Definitely not made for anything above class II.
- the floor was not self-bailing. Total deal breaker, although I think they now provide a self bailing floor
Outcast Striker
Things I liked
- Self bailing floor
- Much more stable
- More compact making it easier to haul with my camper
- Less expensive than the Flycraft
Things I didn't like
- No frame and after several hours on the water my back would really start bothering me
- Anchor system was kind of cheap compared to others
But it ended up being an easy decision and went with the Outcast. I love that little boat. I added a simple NRS frame and that fixed my back issues. Also having a frame, I feel confident enough to row it down our local class IV. Might man up and give it a go this summer as I haven't been down in several years since I sold my 14'er. And while the Scotty Anchor is not bombproof, it is fine for what I'm doing.
Another one you might look at is the Orvis Hookjaw. My friend bought one last year and while I haven't been in it yet, he loves it.
Feel free to hit me up if you want to get out for a day and test drive the Striker. I'm always looking for an excuse...
Bookmarks