What resort race boot would you recommend for someone who only needs a custom footbed and a small punch for a big toe to ski stock Atomic Hawx Ultra? Redsters cs, Lange Rs?
Hawx doesn’t smooth out bad snow as krypton did, but other than that I like them more. My guess is it’s mainly because of the weight difference. So checking my options for a good heavy boot for lift accesses skiing.
You're definitely looking at the right category (Redster CS, Lange RS, etc.) - these boots will have the weight, plastic thickness, damping, stability, etc. you are looking for. But almost all of them fall into the category of "requires fitting out of the box" rather than "automatically fits out of the box". So with any of these boots, just prepare yourself for the out of the box fit not being that comfortable, but it will become comfortable after the fitting. And you'll also need to add on some sort of aftermarket lifter plate for grip/traction/replaceability too. So, there are a few more steps involved in making this category of boot ready to roll vs. a Hawx Ultra or Promachine or RX.
Where does the Salomon S/Max fit in this discussion? Seems stiffer than RX and Promachine but maybe less move flex than the Redster/Raptor/Doberman? Anybody in then and like them a lot?
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Day Man. Fighter of the Night Man. Champion of the Sun. Master of Karate and Friendship for Everyone.
It's the "Variable Arch Tool" from Sidas. The pivotting end breaks after a few weeks of use, what you see has been brazed in place at my bike builder friend's house. Also, the leather pads are not standard but the supplied foam ones disintegrate after a month or so. It also comes with another attachment shaft which is useless - I hacksaw them off and smooth on the grinder (visible on the left side of the arch).
Hey yeah, guess so you find the flex pattern in such a lightweight boot? Haven't been able to try them on yet. My impression of the Promachine is an inconsisten flex pattern and the RX nicer but softish. And how does it change with temp? I'm coming from Nordica Hot Rods that have a nice, beefy flex (when cold), though all time favorite was the grand prix.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Day Man. Fighter of the Night Man. Champion of the Sun. Master of Karate and Friendship for Everyone.
The S/Max stiffen up a bit when it gets cold but not a ton after you get below maybe 10-15 degrees. Flex pattern seems pretty consistent - like it doesn't ramp up. First inch isn't much easier than the last inch, if that makes sense. I feel like you can really feel the snow with them - in a good way. I feel what my skis are doing.
I switched this year to tecnica liners in them, which gave me a bit more width in the toebox. The Salomon liners are fine, but that's about it. Not awesome.
Overall, they are incredibly responsive and reliable. Blister calls them stiffer than most or all 130s out there. That seems right. I think they are quite stiff, but at the same time they don't transmit anything too harsh. Carbon ones are more damp than mine, but I like the snow feel of the non-carbons. Biggest things are that they feel super quick and precise, fit my foot really well, have enough stiffness that I'm not blowing through the flex on landings, let me know what's going on under foot, and do exactly what I tell them to do when I tell them to do it.
Is that really what the lateral aspect of your foot looks like? Just prominent at the fifth met and the styloid? Or is it a smooth curve between the two points? Typically you should bring the punch forward a bit to the fifth phalanges to take pressure off that, too. I'm not there in person, but I'm pretty sure you can get more width out of a Hawx Ultra than that (you should see mine). Try removing the bootboard so you can get down lower in the shell, and use a head that's slightly thicker, not just a ball. (If that's an accurate reflection of what your foot looks like, forget what I said - Brent was always top notch when he was in Seattle).
RX feels plenty stiff when cold, but I only weigh 165. Ex-racer who normally weighs 175-185 when lifting consistently and they were fine then too. This is the pre dual core RX with green buckles. I’m not a fan of Nordicas because the flex seems to be on/off, not progressive like Lange. My Hawx Ultra Professionals feel too springy to me, but they are fun on a groomer ski(Elan Wildcat 85CTi) linking turns at speed.
The forefoot width and overall volume aren't really that different than the Hawx Ultra. The medial side was more difficult, especially around the navicular and at the base over the arch - I ground about 30% of the shell thickness away before I could move the plastic there. I also ended up punching some for the styloids when I never have needed to with the Ultra.
OP Update: Decided to replace my old Raptors with a new pair of WCR 140S that I sized down for an even better fit. Local bootfitter grinded them up in all the hot spots and after a few days they fit perfectly - totally locked it - with the exception of the toe box! Unless I am really driving the boot my big toe presses up against the toe box enough to cause significant pain and discomfort after a full day skiing. One of those things that builds up as the day progresses.
Took them back to the boot fitter for an additional mods and he is pushing back on doing any sort of toe box stretch due to the thickness of the plastic and potentially warping the boot but also says that he can't fit his tool in the toe box to make the proper grind? I don't think this is a big mod (I just need a few mm at most) but I also haven't had to do toe box work before. The shop I used to take my boots to was awesome but they shutdown last year and we don't have a great ski shop network in my city.
PS. Started a new thread but thought I would post my question here as you all have been super helpful/informative.
Bookmarks