Pow skis just boils down to what shape you want at mount point and how you want to drive the skis, or if you want a pow specific shape or a wider am ski that does well in deeper snow (aka difference between say Noctas and Animas).
BG/C&Ds are great if you ski from a centered stance and want to be able to shut down speed effortlessly. BGs crushes variable, while C&Ds slay pow with aplomb. Both are super loose and a pure joy to ski in all forms of soft snow. Neither are good options if you like to drive through your tips aggressively - the tails will wash out. I guess the same goes for SuperGoats, in spite of the tails having slightly less splay, them being slightly wider and stiffer. Dynastar M-Free 118s seems like a ski that kinda bridges the gap between BGs and C&Ds a bit while loosing a bit of performance in variable, but also does better on harder surfaces.
Revolt121s are super interesting, especially mounted two centimeters behind recommended for us more directional peeps. Their flex pattern of stiffer front part and softer mid/aft part together with deep rocker lines and tons of splay should make them a lot more versatile than their -3 mount point suggests, at least for riders who prefer to ski from a bit more centered stance, while still slaying pow with aplomb (in deep snow they will probably ski more or less like a reverse camber ski). I will probably pick up a pair.
I am guessing that 190 Wildcats and 194 Animas are somewhat similar - playful skis that also chargers well. I would perhaps opt for the Wildcat of the two due to their slightly narrower shovels, longer sidecut radius and proven design. The BCs are too expensive for their construction too imho, but oh well marketing eh. Rustler11s should be a tad bit more directional than either, but still fairly loose and easy to pivot. They are not terribly heavy no, but skis surprisingly well across a lof of conditions - I really, really like them - though I have not tried the big boy size.
For Noctas - the general consensus is to go up in length. I have not tried them, but lots of folks seem to enjoy them for playing around in pow. Def not the ski to get if you want to rage through variable though - though they probably do that tolerably well for their weight/shape.
Last but not least, have you considered DPS Koala119s in 190? They ski somewhat like a more centered BG, but have more support in the tails. They are super loose and easy to ski in soft snow, they crush variable and I think they will be strong on edge for heavier / stronger riders on harder snow. You can def get on the shovels, at least more so than BGs. I really liked my pair of 184s, but sold them since I figured their overall stiffness would make them more of a chore in anything but soft for me being a smaller dude at 175cm/65kg w/o gear. I am not positive that that was the right call, but too late now

Yeah, they are DPSs, but still - they rip.
Bookmarks