Since I used the info from this thread to order a couple of the cheaper options, I thought I'd give some feedback on fit. I've got an XL hand, but it's a real mitt with not-especially-long sausage fingers. The Ninja Ice gloves are snug on my fingers and all fingers and thumb are about 1cm too long. The backs are not wind-proof, which may be an issue for riding vs. skinning. The Head gloves from Costco, on the other hand (ahem) are Goldilocks for me fit-wise. Backs are windproof. But I'm concerned that if my hands get the least bit damp from sweat, I'll invert the liner as I remove them and then struggle to get it all lined back up again. Hope that mini-review helps some other cheapskate!