OFFICIAL 2018 MLB THREAD

[ex-powderbroker]

Damnit, The Crime Dog fell off the ballot this year. A deserving player overshadowed by the Balco crowd. Would the 7 dingers he easily would have gotten in the strike shortened season really have made that much of a difference?

McGriff (Like Dwight Evans, Larry Walker, and many others) >>> Jim 'lowering the bar forever with Fenway inflated numbers because he fucking hit .277 .330 .459 away' Rice

What an injustice

[Brock Landers]

Top 5 player in the game for 6-8 year period, to me, gets in.

McGriff was never even remotely in that discussion

[I've seen black diamonds!]

I think McGriff was a lot like Rice in that the last decade of his career was pretty forgettable. Walker is similar to Evans in that they were still all star quality players in their mid-late 30's. Walker also had one legit MVP quality season, even with the Coors inflation. I think Walker is hurt by the Coors inflation because people incorrectly assume he wouldn't have been great anywhere. They're wrong. He was a consistent force in Montreal before the steroid era was even in full swing.

[ex-powderbroker]

Top 5 player in the game for 6-8 year period, to me, gets in.

McGriff was never even remotely in that discussion

4 in the top 10 WAR, mvp votes in ten, career on base of .377. Maybe you just weren't listening to the conversation?

[irul&ublo]

Top 5 player in the game for 6-8 year period, to me, gets in.

McGriff was never even remotely in that discussion

But he had the best nick name

[Brock Landers]

And the best endorsements

[iceman]

Sure, the ESPN ballwashing is nice, but cashing Steinbrenner's fat checks while you're on the disabled list with your 3rd knee scope at age 37 doesn't hurt, either.

haha

[ex-powderbroker]

And the best endorsements

it even says superstar right there

[ex-powderbroker]

aw fuck, frank robinson passed away. before my time but he was not borderline.

[Brock Landers]

Not borderline for sure.

[jasmap]

Damnit, The Crime Dog fell off the ballot this year. A deserving player overshadowed by the Balco crowd. Would the 7 dingers he easily would have gotten in the strike shortened season really have made that much of a difference?

McGriff (Like Dwight Evans, Larry Walker, and many others) >>> Jim 'lowering the bar forever with Fenway inflated numbers because he fucking hit .277 .330 .459 away' Rice

What an injustice

McGriff was a blast to watch and I loved his style of play and how intimidating he was at the plate. I personally couldn't vote him into the hall if I had a vote but he was a damn good ball player. Way above avg. But I see your point because I see Dale Murphy as a HOF player and others don't. Murphy had 2 MVP's, 7 all-star games, led the league in homers and rbi's a few times and was just a killer in the 80's. He had a beast of an arm too. But he was basically held to the 80's with one injury year.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

[Brock Landers]

Dale Murphy was a fucking stud. 2x MVP? Maybe the most feared NL hitter in the 1980s? Yup, first ballot (for me).

McGriff never in the top 8 feared hitters at any point in his career. Maybe he should have juiced (if he didn’t, which is up for debate).

[ex-powderbroker]

murphy led the league in home runs twice and no other categories. both years he won the mvp, a team with mike schmidt would have won more games. if anything his awards just make writers look worse. very good player but not exactly raising the bar either.

paving the way for bernie though and whitaker with the veterans committee.

also mcgriff did lead intentional walks once, which puts at least a ding in the ‘not feared’ argument. he just needed a mazerosky moment or 7 dingers, either one and he’d have a plaque after three votes.

[jasmap]

murphy led the league in home runs twice and no other categories. both years he won the mvp, a team with mike schmidt would have won more games. if anything his awards just make writers look worse. very good player but not exactly raising the bar either.

paving the way for bernie though and whitaker with the veterans committee.

also mcgriff did lead intentional walks once, which puts at least a ding in the ‘not feared’ argument. he just needed a mazerosky moment or 7 dingers, either one and he’d have a plaque after three votes.

Actually Murphy led the league in RBI's twice, runs, total bases, walks, OPS, slugging %, games played, won four Silver Slugger Awards, and five Gold Gloves. Thats with me not including his 7 all-star games and MVP awards as well as being nominated other years also. The home run leading years were not in the same years as when he led in RBI's. So he was a dominant player for the whole decade. I agree Schmidt was likely the most feared hitter in that time though. Schmidt was a badass and intense. Murphy didn't have great teams with the Braves but they were fun to watch. Plus he was considered a nice guy and not seemingly as intense or scary as Schmidt. But yeah Murphy was easily amongst the best of the 80's.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

[ex-powderbroker]

they aren’t a straight comparison but the eras a pretty similar since mcgriff didn’t debut until 86 and it sounds like we can both agree that schmidt was much better than dale murph.

but if you have a guy in the hall that is so clear (schmidt) wouldn’t someone much worse be borderline? and then you make a case for someone demonstrably better in a fairly similar era i just can’t see the lack of support, the writers just have to suck.

regardless:

mcgriff murphy
war 52 46
hr 493 398
rbi 1550 1266
doubles 441 350
walks 1305 986
obp 377 346
slug 509 815
runs created 1704 1308

man looking at the mvp awards and it’s crazy how people get robbed. ripken, bonds, henderson... the 80s would look a lot different if we looked at talent the way we do now.

[SkiBall]

Dale Murphy helped give me some regular baseball entertainment with this new station I discovered called WTBS. Sure I was on the left coast, but I created a bond with these boys in powder blue, NL as they were.
I say let him in.

[ex-powderbroker]

here’s a good article on the hall in general and murphy in particular:


https://www.mlb.com/news/determining...es/c-262969586

[ex-powderbroker]

OH SHIT, the red sox were not able to cheat in the WS because mlb was in the clubhouse.

However:

108*

the Yankees are now the 2017 and 2018 AL East winners.

[ex-powderbroker]

stupid astros cheaters

2017:


2018:

[iceman]

Those numbers certainly don't support the assertion that the Sox were cheating.

[ex-powderbroker]

wrong thread

[ex-powderbroker]

anyway, they were warned not to cheat because of the whole 2017 apple watch thing... fuckers

[The SnowShow]

Cora fiiiiired.

[ex-powderbroker]

Sox 2018 playoffs:

without a runner on 2nd (any number of outs):

.216 BA, .279 OBP, .348 SLG

runner on 2nd (any number of outs):

.368 BA, .455 OBP, .643 SLG

runner on 2nd (2 outs):

.447 BA, .500 OBP, .895 SLG

[mcski]

Cora fiiiiired.

So stupid. All this hand wringing over stealing signs? It’s fucking baseball. That’s their job