Originally Posted by
EWG
Here we go BMills. We're walking the tightrope. Buckle up.
I get the Tretter move. Tretter's getting old for a O lineman. They save 9 mil by moving on. It is highly likely that in 2 years at 34 or 35 he won't be that awesome anymore, so if they think Nick Harris is ready (and he's done ok playing out of position thus far when guys are hurt) and Bill Callahan signs off I understand it. With that move and the other signings they have something like 25mil of cap room right now. They need to sign up their rookie class plus 2 D Linemen plus a WR, so they need to create space. All good.
But it could also be used, combined with removing Baker's deal, to get Watson's salary under the cap.
And that's the tightrope. Cleveland, right now, when healthy, has a QB that can get them to the playoffs and win. He did it in 2020, so we know it's true. Can he win a superbowl? Who knows? But Baker can win in the playoffs. And this is the first time in 25 years that Browns fans could say that.
If they don't get Watson, and they move on from Baker because of going after Watson, there's almost no plan B. Jimmy G? Please. MAYBE Matt Ryan if Watson goes to Atlanta - and Ryan costs as much as Watson. And he's not the future cause he's really old. And there's aren't any QBs in the draft. It feels like the Browns, right now, are at a hugely important point in their history. Berry and Stefanski just swung for the fences (or Haslem?). If they don't hit the homerun, we might just lose everything and go back to wandering the wilderness. I'm scared, and my fan PTSD is kicking in.
The next few days might determine the fate of the Browns for the next 5 years or more.
And by the way - I've thought about it. I would rather fight to make the playoffs every year with Baker - a loyal guy, a good human, a guy who's loved by his teammates and seems to have outstanding character, then win all the time with Watson. That feels like a deal with the devil. I could root for Baker like I rooted for Kosar. Baker would (and almost did last year) kill himself for Cleveland. That matters to me.