Originally Posted by
anotherVTskibum
The UV-5R is functional, and if you're technically capable not all that hard to program, but:
a) it's not actually legal for FRS/GMRS use (probably not a big deal in practice, as getting caught is unlikely)
b) some of them have been tested to not even comply with the FCC certs shown on the radios (they throw spurious transmissions elsewhere on the spectrum, potentially interfering with others' traffic)
c) IMO, there's a significant element of "you get what you pay for" in going with a BCA radio that's built for use in a snowy mountain environment. YMMV; I don't own the BCA radio, as between my UV5R and the blisterpack Motorola GMRS units the wife bought a while ago, we're usually covered (and I carry a commercial handheld when I'm working), but if I were shopping for a skiing-specific radio, especially if I wanted backcountry comms as a significant use case, I'd probably try to suck it up and buy the BCA.