Printable View
Big flap about the Pieps beaconson Instagram and among Facebook friends.
It stems from a crash with pro skier McNutt claiming his beacon malfunctioned.
https://unofficialnetworks.com/2020/...-in-avalanche/
Anybody else have issues? Mine seems to be solid, and I’m curious.
Sounds more like "ice chunks" under fire to me.
Even the prior design had switch issues. When in search mode the top of the plastic switch face protrudes above the beacon body. Sloppy design of an otherwise good beacon.Quote:
Originally Posted by ~mikey b
That is by design, so when you're in search mode and a second avalanche takes out a searcher, the beacon is pushed back into send mode.Quote:
Originally Posted by 3PinGrin
That sounds like Bs.
But... I would be interested in proof that it works that way for a fail safe.
that style switch was more likely to break than function properly in my opinion
I wonder if that’s why the sent me a Powder BT when I sought a repair to my DSP last Spring.
And if the protruding switch (with a hollow back, you know like a scoop) rips off the beacon? Also, how the hell is it supposed to push back into send mode?? It also protrudes in the off mode making it more of a pain in the ass to get out of the harness pouch. I like and trust the beacon, but it's a poorly thought out component of an otherwise good design IMO.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dee Hubbs
I don't worry much in send mode, plus I'm almost always solo so the odds of it breaking in search mode (or me being found if buried) are pretty small. I do ski with partners occasionally and don't worry too much about it because I am cognizant of the issue. If caught in a secondary avalanche, I would think losing the beacon would actually be a bigger concern than the switch. Still sloppy though.Quote:
Originally Posted by ~mikey b
Maybe you are referring to something besides the plastic breaking though? I have wondered about that switch for patrollers and others that put it through the rigors just because the sliding design. I don't know if a contact might wear out or something?
copy that
Are you talking about the version mikey b linked, or the prior version with the protruding switch? What was the issue with the DSP ?Quote:
Originally Posted by Peruvian
I've been travelling the mountains alone for 40 years. If something happens it happens, bfd. I have talked to my kids about knowing that it was exactly what you stated, they are cool with it. I go where I want, when I want, and don't wait on anyone to show up to the party. Any other insight?Quote:
Originally Posted by cmcrawfo
It was the prior yellow/grey version with the slider that protruded past the edge. I brought it to my local dealer who couldn’t update it so it was sent back to SLC and they warranted a Powder BT in its place.Quote:
Originally Posted by 3PinGrin
Thanks for that info Peruvian.Quote:
Originally Posted by Peruvian
3PG
I’m with ya - I do a lot of solo skiing - always have and always will
Thanks mikey b, I get a little crass just because of lectures about travelling solo mostly from people that haven't spent a single night alone in the outdoors. My dad had me doing that and learning how to light a fire in the middle of winter with one match when I was in my early teens.Quote:
Originally Posted by ~mikey b
Also, there is a reason some of the great conservationists and ecologists of our time spent a lot of time alone in the wilderness. You can never soak in and process things in a group the way you can when alone, that's lost on a lot of people though. Plus, I would have spent a lot less time outdoors if I was always trying to plan things with others.
My entire extended family is full of loners, must be genetic, lol. Sorry, rant over, back to beacons. :)
I grew up in the woods alone, I’ll die in the woods alone. And I’m perfectly happy with it!!Quote:
Originally Posted by 3PinGrin
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Point of correction, the switch protruding in search mode was so that THE USER could quickly slap it back into send. Not the avalanche.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dee Hubbs
Tracker 2 was the same concept.
Now I don't like that switch design but at the time that the OG DSP Pro came out it was probably the most technologically advanced beacon on the market. I don't recall when exactly it came out but well over 10 years ago. There are better beacons now.
damn straight!!Quote:
Originally Posted by SoVT Joey
That makes more sense from a design perspective at least. I think sometimes it's easy to focus too much on the positive side of a design concept and get wrapped up in the "eureka" moment without taking a step back to re-evaluate the bigger picture of how it might effect other aspects of the design under real world conditions.Quote:
Originally Posted by adrenalated
It blows me away that any modern beacon doesn't have an auto revert to transmit mode built in, like a decade ago.
^^This
Do they not? The dsp sport and pro both have auto revert to send, at least in the recent iterations.Quote:
Originally Posted by MakersTeleMark
Sent from my Pixel XL using TGR Forums mobile app