The Revenant

[My Pet Powder Goat]

hate to be 'that guy', but the book was way fucking better
i mean shit, he didn't even have a son in the book
movie was weak

Don't lie, you looove being "that guy" ;-)

Ya, his son was fabricated, which is too bad because that was the most poignant part of the film. Honestly much of the film is factually inaccurate.

[Benny Profane]

Sorry, but no way he would have survived, with the loss of blood, and cold. Cmon.

[My Pet Powder Goat]

It's a movie, bunny. The real Glass was mauled by a bear, left for dead, and attacked by Indians on his 200 mile journey home.

[PNWbrit]

Sorry, but no way he would have survived, with the loss of blood.

it wasn't that bad.. only a fucking bear and a bit of cold.

It's not like he fell off a chair lift or something really serious.

[neck beard]

I watched it late during a long a flight and didnt really pay attention, but did they jump from a coastal forest environment to a much drier interior setting, from one scene to the next? After following a river presumably toward the coast?

Early scenes also seemed to be in spring melt, when later scenes were in winter, and a year had not passed. I may be wrong, and doubt 99.99999999% of viewers give a fuck anyway. But if a major theme of the movie was the intensity of nature, then Hollywood could have made a little more effort at providing natural consistency.

[abraham]

I watched it late during a long a flight and didnt really pay attention, but did they jump from a coastal forest environment to a much drier interior setting, from one scene to the next? After following a river presumably toward the coast?

Early scenes also seemed to be in spring melt, when later scenes were in winter, and a year had not passed. I may be wrong, and doubt 99.99999999% of viewers give a fuck anyway. But if a major theme of the movie was the intensity of nature, then Hollywood could have made a little more effort at providing natural consistency.

I pay way too much attention to the scenery in movies. The worst are the ones set in Colorado or Montana and filmed in Vancouver. The forests are so different

[shroom]

lay off that dank dank my dude

[DougW]

I watched it late during a long a flight and didnt really pay attention, but did they jump from a coastal forest environment to a much drier interior setting, from one scene to the next? After following a river presumably toward the coast?

Early scenes also seemed to be in spring melt, when later scenes were in winter, and a year had not passed. I may be wrong, and doubt 99.99999999% of viewers give a fuck anyway. But if a major theme of the movie was the intensity of nature, then Hollywood could have made a little more effort at providing natural consistency.

My beef was his journey seemed to go from forested foothills to rolling plains back into high mountain valleys back to low foothills then final shots in mountains ( on location of old ski hill that I skied for 4 years). Weather not an issue as Alberta weather is that variable. No Leo its not global warming its just a chinook you dumb MF.

[Meadow Skipper]

Here you go guys, critique it:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1663202/...ref_=tt_trv_gf

[Benny Profane]

I watched it late during a long a flight and didnt really pay attention, but did they jump from a coastal forest environment to a much drier interior setting, from one scene to the next? After following a river presumably toward the coast?

Early scenes also seemed to be in spring melt, when later scenes were in winter, and a year had not passed. I may be wrong, and doubt 99.99999999% of viewers give a fuck anyway. But if a major theme of the movie was the intensity of nature, then Hollywood could have made a little more effort at providing natural consistency.

There were a few scenes where he literally went from fresh two to three feet of snow to old snow and then back.

[ex-powderbroker]

If you want to see a western, check out Hateful Eight. How Tarantino can keep making real masterpieces for zero credit, I don't understand. This movie has everything Revenant fails at. Real character development, a fucking plot, clever dialogue, and it's really well shot to boot. The performances he gets out of Kirk Russell and Jennifer Leigh are incredible. He also seems to capture the spirit of the times in a weird post war way better than Leo's period schlock. But Quentin is too outsider for a nice review? Violent? It isn't his turn? What gives?

[shroom]

hateful either and the revenant were both solid. I hadn't thought about it, but I think I agree with your comparison.

[neck beard]

I saw Hateful 8 on the same flight as Revenant. It was better. The chick was funny. Plenty of it was amusing actually ("sneaky sack shooter".) But it was too violent. Setting out the rope line to the outhouse was a surprising bit of pragmatic drudgery. Were we supposed to feel suspense? Or was that the point, as a lead up to the violence? At least it paid respect to the nature of the environment, unlike Revenant.

While I am getting off topic: I fucking hate Game of Thrones snow, It looks completely wrong. And if it so damned cold and wet, why doesn't anyone ever wear a hat? So much effort goes into their realistic sets and costumes, yet that get these basics so wrong.